Was out twice this week, here’s what to expect. Tuesday and Thursday were cold, overcast and windy. 38 felt like 17 and the push of cold air from the North at 15-20 was not as pleasant as I might have hoped. Streams are extremely clear and the best approach is from down stream, making long upstream casts. Even the deeper water appeared shallow and one could see the bottom in most places even without the sun. No fast water fish yet even though I checked the likely spots. Fish that I caught tended to lie in slower dark bottom areas against stream banks where sighting them was almost impossible. These darker areas will warm a bit more. Deep still water pools are holding fish but drifting a nymph to them is like bobber fishing and very boring even along the seams where you could get some drift to the indicator. This is a bit perplexing but it is what it is.
The lower Kinni gave me the 3rd skunk in a row. I have now fished the middle in two spots and Tuesday I fished the dam section from Glen park down. I was greeted with a disgusting racial slur spray painted and scrolled across the hydro wall of the lower dam. The picture above shows last years youth art project simply naming the dam FRED. The city obviously painted the walls of the structure gray to cover over FRED. This week something much darker was in its place. I took a picture simply for documentation. I will not post it for that would be playing into the hands of the perpetrator and spreading his/her message. As I pondered the ugliness of it all, no fish, the thoughtless message, the decaying concrete and the break in the natural flow of nature, it once again reinforced the obvious. I would rather have Falls than Walls. Mr. Toland, Mr.Simpson tear down those walls!
Thursday I fished elsewhere. Cold, ugly, but I caught 4 nice trout and missed another. I worked hard, stayed stealthy, paid attention to everything around me and made adjustments. I came home happy and content.
I was re-reading my copy of Spring Creeks by Mike Lawson. His life long book and an excellent read. I met Mike in 2004 or 5 when he was the guest speaker at Tom Helgeson’s Greatwaters Fly Fishing Expo. In early for the show I was able to take him and his wife Sheralee to see the Kinni, the Rush and the Trimbelle. He had never been to this part of the country. The waters were high and dirty. We talked instead of fished. He was impressed with our waters and provided me with thoughtful insight. The beginning of chapter 11 of his book titled “Responsibilities” begins with these words.
“For whatever reason men fish, they are rewarded simply by the things they see. All the mechanisms of life are visible to those who look for them, from the nature of the very smallest creature to the natures of men. A mans behavior on the stream is likely to tell much about the kind of man he is.” Steve Raymond. Although these are not Mike’s words he has brought them to light in Spring Creeks. The rest of the chapter is filled with the same insightful commentary pertaining to situations we are, or will be facing, here on our home waters. They are wise words.
Catch me some fish this weekend please, and report back if you can.
44 users commented in " Quickie #2 Week of 3/24-27 "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackGoater, thanks for not sharing the pic. left by creeps. Ya done good there…
Appreciate the commentary as always, especially about Mike Lawson. I’ve always wanted to meet him and it was must’ve been really cool to show he and his bride some water, even just to look. Good to hear his response.
I’ve not fished yet but I’m ready. Damned ready. Early this morn. before we hit the gym it was single digit temps. SINGLE DIGITS!!!
Hope to bump elbows with you sometime.
Keep your nose clean Andrew. Good health!!
Hey Andy,
Well I finally have a fly rod and am going to start using it soon. I actually won it at the fly fishing film tour! I need to set up a few hour lesson with you. On a side note, my brother just purchased 40 acres by Prairie Farm, WI. Vance Creek runs right through the property. I was curious if you’ve ever fished it or any of the streams near there. The Hay River, Connor’s Creek, etc… Anyways, I’m looking forward to learning to fly fish. I’m sick of spin fishing.
Nice post Andy.
Thanks!
Rusty
Skunked again on the lower Kinni! No hits, rises, or trout even seen as well (Fri. 3/27) 1:30-4:30. They cant ALL be hiding down in deep pools somewhere (can they)?? I’m starting to get even more concerned about the state of the trout population here. A couple events and conversations today lead to this. There was ample insect activity in the air and on the water, mostly midges but there was also a good small mayfly hatch as well (BWOs?) that lasted for over an hour while I was fishing one of my favorite riffle-runs. It seemed in other years around this time if you saw mayflies hatching typically it would be “game on” in this area. You would also usually see multiple fish constantly rising all up and down this stretch.
I met two fly-fishers today both reporting skunks on the water, one guy said “I haven’t even seen a fish yesterday” (assuming this was his second consecutive day on the water skunked with no fish seen). I also had a conversation with a local gentleman from the River Falls Fire Dept. walking his dog on the trail asking me about my success. He said he asks everyone he meets on the trail and he hasn’t heard of any success lately. He shared that a guy he knows has seven consecutive skunks on the lower Kinni this year. He said he is very concerned as well.
By my Norwegian math Andy that makes my 2 skunks + your 3 + 7 from the friend of the dog walker + 3 guys I met on the water = 15 in the last couple weeks. I did meet one pair of fly fishers last week that reported a couple (2?) fish between them around 10″. That is the only success I have heard of on the lower Kinni lately.
Any more insight/ideas Andy or anyone else?? Anyone catching or even seeing fish on the lower Kinni?
Friday, March 28
I fished Friday afternoon at 570th on the Rush River. The water is very clear and running at about a normal flow. The air temperature was about 32 to 36°.
There were no fishermen cars at the bridge. There also were no fishermen at the Kinni McDonald bridge. I feared the season had been closed or was closed for the rest time before the kill season. I decided to fish anyway.
I put the long johns on for warmth along with three other layers. It was clear and cold and windy. I sat at the run just upstream of the bridge to tie on a light tippet and my fly. There were some fish rising so it looked good. The small olives were coming off and being blown away. But I did see some rises. I tied on a freshly tied BWO. I tied up 5 last night being an optimist. It was quick. They liked my size 17 thread fly with trailing shuck and simple hackle wing. Very tasty. I left two in the trees… Windy day! I caught three nice browns. And saw lots of fish midging in the clear glassy water. The fish are back.
I’ll be bouncing all across southeast MN trouting all week if you want to hop the border to the land of no Sunday beer sales.
DA
I will shoot you an email.
A
Pete Jay
Nice report. Way to feed the fish and the trees:)
Doodle
Thanks for the report on the lower Kinni. The only way we will know what’s up is to keep fishing it. I am documenting the stretches I have fished so far and the results. I will continue, and I hope others do as well so we can keep up the data string. Things will change or they won’t, one way we will know more is if we continue. I know angling is a very inexact science but it is time in the water and observation.
Roger that Rusty
A
Luke
Great luck. So your the one who stuffed that bucket! Lessons are good You will be hooked. Keep me in the loop.
Jeremy
The warmth this week should draw you out of your cocoon. BWOS starting to show
Andy:
My fishing buddy Duane and I were both skunked again on Saturday.
I’m still looking to catch my first trout of the 2014 season.
Now I understand the appeal of muskie fishing.
Jaybird
Hi Andy,
I spent over four hours on the Lower Kinni today (Sunday 3/29) – second skunk in a row. Plenty of midges and olives but no risers and no hits subsurface either. Only two other fisherman out – one said he got one fish, the other guy didn’t have any luck when I passed him going downstream. Water looked great, bugs coming off, but no fish.
Hi guys,
Fished the upper Kinni both Sat and Sun. The skunk followed me where ever I went. Did not see a rise, did not see a fish, the few other anglers I spoke to reported the same. Sat. the water temp was 38 on Sun it was 41. Midges on Saturday and Sun there were tons of midges, a few stones, and one of the best BWO hatches I have seen on the upper Kinni for years but like I said, not a single rise. Tried every nymph/streamer in the box – nothing.
This time of year, fishing around here is usually too easy, but as everyone knows that is not the case this spring. I keep making excuses: it was too cold on Sat., too windy on Sun, hoping that the fish numbers are still there, but I’m losing hope. I can’t get out until next weekend, when it is supposed to cool down again, but I am interested to see if things pick up during the week, with the hatches starting to pop and temps in the mid 60s – if the fish are there, the fishing should be good. Good luck!
Greg
goat,
i talked to several anglers who at least saw fish in stretches where anglers noticed no fish the first week of fishing. and a few who have been catching on the kinni who were also skunked earlier on.
also one who reported a giant deep hole that gets almost zero fishing pressure and lost count at 100 fish schooled up, estimated over 200.
it should warm up soon and fish should start spreading out.
Hi Brian
Thanks for the comment, all good news. Will give another crack at the lower the next couple of days to see if I can stir up a few.
A
Hey Greg
Keep up the strong effort. Hope is there, she is just a bit smarter this week since she was caught and released last week. The survey data shows there has been a change. We have been thrown a curve ball and the puzzle has become more difficult to solve. That is part of our challenge. Keep looking for an answer.
Less trout + abundant food + cold water temps + spooky clear conditions, may equal= lethargic trout with little reason to eat our poorly presented(no disrespect to your presentation)imitations attached to a string.
There is a challenge out there and it is up to keep banging away in order to uncover some possible answers.
Great feedback.
Thanks Peter
Good to talk with other anglers. The norm at this time of the year is to be slapping each other on the back and enjoying the prideful conversation of how successful of hunters we are. At least for what we have been seeing the coin has been flipped in this short period of time. There are many lessons to be learned from the flip side. I will see you on the river.
Jaybird
I am tying you up some foot long, articulated BWO’s right now. I hear there are some lunkers down at the mouth of the river. I will wait with baited breath to hear the story of the first hook-up.
I don’t fish for slime or their hyped-up more famous relative.
But, thanks for thinking of me.
Headed out again today. Maybe today all the trout will come out of hiding.
Jaybird
Andy,
Did a little wandering on Sunday. Looked at a couple of the improved sections on the Trimbelle. Fishing was tough so I spent some time just walking the banks. Saw two decent sized pods of Hoovers (suckers) but only about 6-8 small trout. No hookups. Also, I didn’t fish but looked at the Isabella. Lot’s of skinny water with the low clear conditions. But… In two spots I would have expected to see trout I saw trout!
I do have a positive contribution for angler’s having limited success on the Lower Kinni. Last week was my spring break and I caught two fish in one afternoon and lost two fish as well. Not the success we are all used to in previous seasons but I’ll take it considering the circumstances.
I fished for six hours yesterday on a stretch of river I know like the back of my hand.
In the afternoon I had perfect light conditions to look into the river. I could see right to the bottom of the river in all the deepest holes except two.
I saw very few fish.
The good news is, about noon I found a pod on maybe ten fish feeding on midges.
I hooked eight and landed six on my copy of Rene Harrops captive midge in size #22.
On my fourth trip of the season I finally broke the skunk!
Jaybird
I love that pattern. Well done!
A
Dave
She is coming around. I heard of 6 caught off the lower dam yesterday.
JL
Isabella is a fickle woman:)
The slime lovers will be mad at you.
ha ha ha, “slime lovers”
So be it…I’m a trout snob and proud of it.
Finally got out on one of those tiny Brook Trout streams around RF today. My first, and only, colorful brookie was followed by my 6 year old’s first trout on the fly. I was definitely more excited than he was. Had to share with you fellow enthusiasts. That’s my report. Sorry, no report on the Kinni for today.
Yesterday I fished the middle section of the Rush, an area I know very well after many years of fishing. The river is very low and gin clear. I fished for probably 4 hours with my friend, another very experience fly-fisherman. Between us we caught 4 fish. I fished hard two of my all time favorite spots and pulled blanks there! Very few fish feeding on the surface despite a nice midge hatch and a few smaller mayflies. I wish I had better news, not good.
3/31/15 Fished 3 bridges on the Rush.
No fish. 5 others had the same result.
Beautiful day, water temp 41’F.
One guy caught a 12″ and a 14″ sitting on the bank
using a Gold Rib hares ear. They looked big, #12 or #14.
I alway fish #16 or smaller. Maybe it’s time for a change
of tactics. I’m an early riser so I’m on the stream early,
maybe a later start is the answer.
P.S. When does the early season end?
I fished the upper Kinni at the swinging gate for the last 1.5 hours of light left in the day (April 1st). Water temp had warmed to 50 degrees and tons of midges about. Not a single rise was spotted, no fish caught, and no fish seen.
Time to head up to the Brule. If I am going to cast and cast hoping for 1 hookup, it might as well be for a steelhead, right?
Greg
Greg
Find me that big one! See ya when you get back.
mwmed
Don’t be lulled by the small stuff. You are really hungry. In front of you is a 16oz T-bone steak, and a piece of popcorn. Which do you choose? The early season ends Sunday April 26th at 11:59 PM and remains closed until the first Sat in May
Duck
It is news, not good or bad, it just is. The flip side was easy abundant fishing. Working hard is a challenge. Learning to be satisfied with less is difficult. Fly Fishing is still fun.
Ericd
Hats of to ya mate. What a great moment. He will always remember.
Ding, Ding, Ding.
You two fight this out somewhere else.
Fished the lower kinni today, one fish, very few rising fish even with lots bugs, still a great day to be on the river. Helped an inebriated canoer out of a jam when he took a wrong turn around an island and he thanked me with a beer! I happily drank it and said a little prayer that he makes it to bridge!
Happy Easter!
Would up fishing the Rush yesterday from 9am-1pm with a good friend. Water temp was 40 degrees. Got a few browns in the 16 in range nymphing. Not aggressive takes and they were still in the deep holes. Had a 15 in brookie come unbuttoned – that hurt. Saw quite a few fish too which was encouraging. Lots of midges and a few BWOs. Also got a 18″ sucker. Hey, with how tough fishing has been for me this year – I’m counting that!
Greg
THANKS GREG KEEP COUNTING
Strong work Joe, sounds like that boater needed it!
Leave A Reply