It was 7:15 p.m. and 3 deer stood in the middle of the road on my approach to River Falls proper. They seemed contented to engage my truck in a stare-down rather than getting the hell out of the way. When the largest of the three began the leg stomp on the pavement, a behavior I have seen before when deer are alarmed, uncertain or getting ready to charge, I decided to call the four legged’s bluff and moved slowly forward. I figured with 265,000 miles on the F-150 and little time left before dark to make a few casts, I would be allowed to pass or I would procure some extra fly tying materials. From past experience it is best to always take a truck to a deer fight. As I inched forward, the fluffy suburban varmint who initiated this stand-off took a step forward. In the final second before the three white flags went up and the trio slowly sauntered off through the rain gardens at the edge of town, I swear, I swear that the largest one cracked a smile and winked at me. She was no farther than 3 feet from the hood of my truck and I was clearly watching for facial expressions. Later I would take this as a sign:)
I had three errands to run before I could proceed to my fishing relaxation destination. Pick up my Mother’s perscriptions at Wallgreens, Check Ace Harware for deck stripper and stop at the first National Bank to make a deposit. The deer had cost me some time and I was a bit anxious. Martha and I had spent the day working on stripping the stain off our deck. This process for those of you who have partaken know that it does not move the needle on the fun meter. I was feeling like my bride and I had achieved a significant goal for the day and of course I like to reward myself for a job well done with a bit of fishing relaxing. My 82 year old Mother, who has lived with us since last October, has now been trained to call it relaxing instead of fishing. I like that. I often now hear her ask if “I am going relaxing”. The bank was closed. Ace had no stripper and the perscriptions took a bit of time to fill.
It was almost 8 when I parked my truck by the tennis courts and started down the long stairway as I had done many times over the last 3 decades. I would get an hour and a half before I could no longer see. As I stepped off the bottom stair I could see there was another angler on the far side of the dam throwing the dry fly at numerous fish that were rising. I asked him if it would be OK if I fished the close side where I was standing. He kindly said yes. He was young and was making his best effort at drifting flies down stream to the trout showing their lips to him. I watched him while I nymphed the current tongues closest to me. I observed him change pattern after pattern, later admitting he had thrown his entire fly box at those fish. I could tell he was paying attention to me as well, as his head would slightly turn each time another trout would flop around on the surface attached to my hook. I had been in his shoes before, we all have and when he left the dam pool for the evening we chatted. I gave him the fly pattern that had worked for me that night and offered a bit of advice on the techniques I had been using. He reminded me of myself just last week so many years ago.
The river was mine now and the comfort of dark and familiarity of place was relaxing. I struggled to see my indicator as it drifted down along the the flat slow seam in the middle of the dam pool. Good fortune deemed I would not need my eye sight for the next trout that took my fly. As my fly line darted, I instinctively set back. The set was tight, but I was not ready for the next play. With rod tip high, the trout jerked my rodtip back to the water. I would like to say I calmly bowed to the fish as would be correct technique written in so many publications, but I am not certain this would be entirely true. For the first time in 32 years a trout was stripping line from my reel. The dam pool on the lower Kinni is the widest section of water in the lower river and this fish headed for the deep cut across the river where the young angler had thrown so many casts earlier in the evening.
As I relive the fight it was everything I would have expected from a wild brown trout born in the river I love. There were two exits from the water. One at distance where I could only feel the weight of the trout and hear the splash as she belly flopped in the flat water pool and one last burst ten feet from me just before she came to hand. I remember my conversation with myself and the repeated plea for the chance to just hold the prize for a moment. Besides a peck on the cheek and reverant thanks the trout did not leave the water.
Photos rarely tend to do justice to the beauty of the moment, at least mine. The auto-flash of the camera at night reflecting and dissolving the colors of the quarry into shades of one, the anxiety and the angles of the quick composition, the effort of the lone angler to document his catch. The beauty is in the memory of the moment and they say fish get bigger and better as time goes on. All will be true of this photo. I finally broke the 20″ mark with this fish, and I marked my rod with the stubby grease pencil I have carried for years. Measured at home the fish was just over 22″. There was no tail pinch because fish do not swim with their tails pinched nor do they like it. The size is not of importance to me except that it is the largest fish that I have ever caught from the Kinni in over 3 decades. I knew it the first time I saw her. Upon release, she swam away like a bolt of lightning.
An ironic twist to this story;
One cast before I landed this brown, I landed a 14 3/4″ male brook trout(no tail pinch). I was going to end the night on a high point since this was the largest brook trout I had ever caught on the Kinni. I preach and try to practice this kind of ending to an outing but couldn’t help but to put the “one more cast” rule into effect Go Figure!
27 users commented in " Go Figure! "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackGreat story my friend, and what a couple of fish to boot!
With all the work you do, you deserved those fish. Love the spot your talking about, I have done quiet well there this year after our day trip together.
Andy – Great story!
To go from the frustration of having to get through a checklist of things you needed to do before you could get in the water, to catching the two biggest fish of each kind you’ve ever landed there? I bet the drive home was a lot different than the drive there…
Bob
Beautiful fish Andy — long and deep too! A little payback for helping out the inexperienced angler. What nymph did you catch it on?
Thanks TB
I was not sure if I would write the story or not. Glad I did.
Bob
A bunch head shaking and disbelief
Thanks jrs
It was big(#8) and ugly and it represented a high calorie meal. Sorry man, I have to think about that one.
Congratulations Andy!, Last year I landed 2 brown trout on the Kinni that were close but no cigar. One was 18″ and the other 19″. I recently landed my first 20 inch brown in a Western Wisconsin stream not named the Kinnickinnic and it was great but I would trade three 20 inchers from other rivers to be able to say I did it on the Kinni. Thanks for sharing!
Eddie
Thanks
Just read your blog. Great job on your big August brown.
congratulations.two fine fish and a great story!
A virtual high five! That’s a Helluva fish!
You’re underselling the Brookie a bit, that’s fine fish in it’s own right.
I think it’s even better that you accomplished it in such a high traffic zone, well done!
Wonderful story Andy! You sent me a Big Ugly as a bonus fly this spring (Thanks!) – I’ll try to get to the Kinni this week and try it! (I used to fish with a big ugly, but I haven’t seen him much since he moved to South Dakota.)
Andy
You are right on the undersell. Probably because I was so disappointed in the photo I took. I actually snapped a photo of the brookie too, but the night flash just destroyed the color of the beautiful male brookie and it was a bad photo to boot. To then show the photo just to verify size seemed to be a complete crime. I probably would not gotten a photo of the brown(not that it was a good photo) if not for the brookie because the camera was still lying out on the rock. All in all the brookie kind of got 2nd billing.
Byrd
I don’t know what your talking about. Wink, wink, nudge, nudge.
Thanks John
Glad you liked it.
“For the first time in 32 years a trout was stripping line from my reel.”…
That alone was worth the read Andy.
An amazing fish and maybe just a little bit of payback for being such a “joe” to that young guy…who looked pretty intent on making it work by himself.
Nice story man!
Jeremy.
Andy,
Great story, as always. As I recently mentioned, I love your site and stories. Helps me get my fishing fix. Too bad the brookie photo didn’t turn out. Keep up the good work!
David
Great story and gorgeous brown! I’ve never fished the Kinni before, I think I have to head over there sometime:)
Tight Lines,
Conner
Nice job on those two Andy. Sounds like a nice way to waste away an hour and a half “relaxing”.
Scott
Wow!
Congrats!!
Not surprisingly, this is now the “hottest” trout hole in all of Wisco. Possibly a bit too much of a kiss and tell?
Thanks Jeremy
Haven’t looked back at the story but probably should have clarified that it was the first time in 32 years that a trout from the Kinni was stripping line from my reel. Needless to say because it was the first trout river I had ever fished, it felt like the first time.
Thanks Neighbor
Deuce
Thanks for your comment and for reading the story.
Possibly a bit too much tell, but oh what a kiss.
Awesome fish! Even more awesome that it’s from the Kinni.
I don’t think this is too much kiss and tell. That particular hole was already one of the most fished in the state. Do you really think you are going to drive more traffic from this? Because I don’t…
Congrats, Andy! And as others have said, you certainly deserve it.
Kyle
I think you are hitting the nail. The dam has been the most popular spot on the river since they put in the dam in the 50’s I believe. It is also the main public entrance to the lower river which has few accesses to begin with. More anglers, boaters, and college coeds have used this hole since its creation than any location on the river. Nothing new here.
I think you ought to share the photo of that brookie anyway! Cowboy Bob
C Bob
The photo was too disappointing and has already gone the way of bad photos in my library.
Leave A Reply